Norwegian Ministry of Finance Responds to Offshore Aquaculture Criticism: Offshore and Nearshore Aquaculture Differ in Several Respects
The Norwegian government this week sent the draft offshore aquaculture area allocation regulation out for consultation, but the tax regime for offshore aquaculture remains unclear. SalMar's strategy director criticized the uncertain investment conditions, and the State Secretary at the Ministry of Finance responded that the 2024 budget has made clear that no resource tax will be imposed on offshore aquaculture.
The Norwegian government this week submitted the draft offshore aquaculture area allocation regulation (områdetildelingsforskriften for havbruk til havs) for consultation, but uncertainty surrounding the tax regime for offshore aquaculture has drawn industry criticism. Ellen Reitan (Labour Party), State Secretary at the Norwegian Ministry of Finance, responded to this on 20 November, stating that offshore aquaculture and nearshore aquaculture differ in several respects.
Reitan said the government had already emphasized in the 2024 national budget that it is not appropriate at present to introduce a resource tax (grunnrenteskatt) on offshore aquaculture. She also noted that the government has submitted an aquaculture industry report and an animal welfare report, setting a new direction for future aquaculture regulation, and is currently following up on these reports and related requests from the Storting. Quoting the general principles of the offshore aquaculture report supported by the Storting, Reitan said the key is not how much is produced, but how it is produced.
The criticism has focused mainly on the unclear tax regime. SalMar Strategy Director Runar Sivertsen criticized the unclear investment conditions, arguing that if the framework conditions make offshore aquaculture investment "economically irresponsible," then opening new areas will not help much. iLaks editor-in-chief Aslak Berge also criticized the government in a commentary article, touching on the uncertainty over tax issues and the slow response to the aquaculture industry's development needs.
Gustav Witzøe, who moved early into offshore aquaculture platforms, and SalMar fear that a resource tax could be introduced only after offshore aquaculture proves profitable—a risk they are unwilling to bear. Berge suggested clarifying the resource tax issue in advance, or excluding a resource tax for a set period.
The Norwegian Ministry of Trade, Industry and Fisheries (NFD) was asked about risk-sharing and assessments related to introducing a resource tax, and whether a resource tax could be excluded for a certain number of years into the future; the ministry referred the questions to the Ministry of Finance. In her response, Reitan cited the assessment made when the government handled the 2024 budget: offshore aquaculture is at an early development stage and is not yet profitable; the government judged at the time that "it is uncertain whether the industry will be profitable, and even more uncertain whether it will generate excess returns." The assessment also noted that, to the ministry's knowledge, no studies currently show that offshore aquaculture would generate resource rents, and that it is highly uncertain whether technological development could bring resource rents to the industry in the long term; over time, opportunities could also arise to conduct offshore aquaculture in sea areas closer to large markets. The assessment stated that imposing a resource tax on offshore aquaculture in Norway would make relocation more attractive, and that under a special resource tax, participants could ultimately find themselves in a situation where the tax value of their innovation and investment in Norway is refunded while potential revenue is taxed in other producing countries with suitable sea areas.
Reitan also said the government attaches importance to providing businesses with stable and predictable framework conditions.

Comments(0)
No comments yet. Be the first to comment.