Russia Holds Its Ground on Krill and Toothfish Management at CCAMLR's 45th Meeting, with Several Issues Left Without Consensus
On November 19, 2026, the 45th meetings of the Scientific Committee and the Commission of the Commission for the Conservation of Antarctic Marine Living Resources (CCAMLR) were held in Hobart, Australia. The Russian delegation set out its positions on krill fishery management, toothfish resource surveys and the establishment of marine protected areas, and the meeting failed to reach consensus on several key issues.
On November 19, 2026, the 45th meetings of the Scientific Committee and the Commission of the Commission for the Conservation of Antarctic Marine Living Resources (CCAMLR) were held in Hobart, Australia. According to the Russian fisheries news website Fishnews, the most contentious issues at this meeting included the resource management of krill and toothfish, and the establishment of a system of marine protected areas within the Convention area. The Russian delegation, with scientific support from the Russian Federal Research Institute of Fisheries and Oceanography (VNIRO), submitted 5 Russian documents at the meeting, and another 11 documents had already been submitted to CCAMLR working groups during the 2026 intersessional period.
Commission members attending the meeting included Australia, Argentina, Belgium, Brazil, Germany, the European Union, India, Italy, Spain, China, South Korea, Namibia, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Poland, the Russian Federation, the United Kingdom, the United States, Ukraine, Uruguay, France, Chile, Sweden, Ecuador, South Africa and Japan. Mauritius, Peru, Canada, Panama, Finland, Colombia and the UAE attended as observers, and a number of non-governmental organizations also sent representatives.
Krill management: Russia opposes linking Subarea 48.1 management to the marine protected area proposal
During the meeting, krill resource management was one of the longest-running debates. According to VNIRO, revising the krill resource management strategy for Area 48 (the Atlantic Antarctic part, ACAA) is a key task for CCAMLR in recent years, and its primary element is changing the way the krill fishery is managed in the Antarctic Peninsula subarea (Subarea 48.1). Russian scientists pointed out that the development of the krill fishery management scheme lacks the necessary and sufficient scientific basis and is instead based on assumptions about the impact of the fishery on the ecosystem.
Russia paid particular attention to the proposal by some countries to harmonize the krill fishery management scheme for Subarea 48.1 with the proposal for a marine protected area in Domain 1 (MPAD1). This area covers the Antarctic Peninsula region, the southern Scotia Sea arc and the western Bellingshausen Sea. Such harmonization would mean restricting fishing activity in the Antarctic Peninsula and South Orkney Islands regions, namely reducing the total allowable catch in the months of January to April, when krill fishing is most efficient, pushing fishing vessels into less productive areas, and establishing spatial closures that further restrict the fleet's access to traditional krill fishing grounds.
The Russian delegation continued the position it took at the previous meeting, maintaining and recording the following position: harmonizing krill fishery management with the ACAA marine protected area proposal lacks legal and scientific basis. Russia maintains that the fishery in Subarea 48.1 should be conducted within the ACAA harmonized management framework, and proposed that management measures be developed on the basis of the spatial distribution patterns of krill, scientific indicators of the status of krill-dependent predator populations (seabirds and marine mammals), and criteria for assessing the potential impact of the fishery on the ecosystem.
Ultimately, the Scientific Committee and the Commission at the 45th meeting failed to reach consensus on revising the krill fishery management strategy for Subarea 48.1. Under the current conservation measure CM 51-01, the krill allowable catch in Area 48 is 5.61 million tonnes, with a threshold catch limit of 620,000 tonnes also applying. The Commission and the Scientific Committee failed to reach consensus on spatial allocations of the threshold catch. VNIRO noted that, as a result, in the ACAA 2026/27 season, under the Olympic-style fishing regime, the krill threshold catch of 620,000 tonnes may be reached regardless of how the catch is spatially distributed among Subareas 48.1 to 48.4.
Russia also raised the need to revise the protocol for scientific observers collecting krill samples from commercial catches. Russian experts stressed that the current requirement (measuring 200 specimens within three fishing days) lacks scientific basis and does not take into account the spatiotemporal heterogeneity of the krill length composition in the fishing area. The Scientific Committee supported Russia's proposal to develop standard requirements for data collection protocols for scientific observers in the krill fishery, requiring consideration of daily trawl counts and catch volumes.
VNIRO also noted that the krill and finfish (lanternfish, icefish) resource surveys conducted aboard the research vessel "Atlantida" will help develop Antarctic fisheries management measures based entirely on science and create favorable conditions for the development of the Russian krill fishery and other Antarctic fishing targets.
Toothfish: disagreement over the Subarea 58.4.1 survey program and tag-recapture rates remains unresolved
On the toothfish issue, VNIRO pointed to the problem of standardizing resource surveys, particularly the resource survey program in Subarea 58.4.1. This program is implemented by five countries—Australia, South Korea, Japan, Spain and France—involving 7 vessels, and has been closed since 2018 due to methodological problems and low efficiency. The Russian delegation maintained its position: a multi-vessel program in Subarea 58.4.1 can only be implemented on the basis of standardized gear, a stratified randomized layout of fishing effort, and the necessary spatial overlap of tagging.
The Scientific Committee and the Commission failed to reach consensus on continuing the Subarea 58.4.1 survey program. The issue of standardizing toothfish resource surveys was moved to the level of the classification of research fishing within CCAMLR's regulatory framework. The Russian delegation had submitted corresponding proposals to revise CCAMLR's regulatory system at the 44th meeting.
The Scientific Committee and the Commission also failed to agree on raising the toothfish tag overlap rate stipulated in conservation measure CM 41-01. The proposal recommended raising the tag overlap rate from 60% to 80%. The Russian delegation argued and recorded its position: amending CM 41-01 requires a scientific basis based on a comprehensive analysis of tag overlap rates and of tag release and recapture indicators.
In addition, the Patagonian toothfish fishery in Subarea 48.3 (the South Georgia Island region, under UK jurisdiction) has been closed since the 2023 season due to irrational exploitation of the resource. Russia reiterated the need for an international longline survey to obtain data independent of the fishery for assessing the distribution, structure and population size of Patagonian toothfish in Subarea 48.3. According to the Russian delegation's position, the Scientific Committee and the Commission at the 45th meeting failed to reach consensus on the UK proposal to set catch limits in Subarea 48.3 for the 2026/2027 season.
Marine protected areas: Russia and China continue to block the establishment of large-scale protected areas
VNIRO noted that, under the guise of environmental protection, relevant parties continue to push in a targeted manner for the establishment of large marine protected areas within the CCAMLR area, closing traditional and potential krill and fish fishing grounds, including Domain 1, East Antarctica and the Weddell Sea. The delegations of the Russian Federation and China did not allow the Scientific Committee and the Commission to reach consensus on establishing such marine protected areas.
According to the December 2025 import and export statistics of the General Administration of Customs of China, under the customs commodity classification (HS 03036700 frozen Alaska pollock, 03047500 frozen Alaska pollock fillets, 03049400 frozen Alaska pollock meat), Russia's exports of Alaska pollock to China in December 2025 amounted to 161.772 tonnes, with an export value of USD 407,031.0 and an average export price of USD 2,516.08 per tonne. This tariff code classification remained stable throughout the period from 2015 to 2026, with no generational changes.

Comments(0)
No comments yet. Be the first to comment.